Bongiorno's New York Pizzeria

Located in the heart of Temecula, Bongiorno's New York Pizzeria is a go-to destination for those craving an authentic slice of New York-style pizza. This cozy eatery brings the unmistakable flavors and craftsmanship of classic New York pies right to Southern California, boasting a menu that’s as inviting as it is satisfying.

The star of the show here is undoubtedly their hand-tossed pizza crust, which strikes the perfect balance between a crisp exterior and an airy, soft interior — a feat that many pizzerias strive for but few achieve. Whether you opt for the iconic Cheese Pie Special, available in both 14" and generous 18" sizes, or the richly layered House Pie Special featuring spinach, pepperoni, bacon, garlic, and feta, each bite delivers a harmonious medley of fresh, robust flavors. The melted mozzarella cheese blends seamlessly with the rich tomato sauce, creating a comforting yet vibrant taste that lingers long after the last slice.

Besides pizza, Bongiorno’s also offers thoughtfully crafted appetizers such as their handcrafted meatballs served with classic marinara — both with and without melted cheese — and golden garlic rolls that pair delightfully well with their signature sauces like creamy ranch or tangy buffalo. These small plates act as the perfect introduction or accompaniment to your main dish, each bite bursting with warmth and homestyle goodness.

Stepping inside Bongiorno’s, you’ll find a welcoming atmosphere that’s relaxed yet polished, with seating available both indoors and outdoors. It’s the kind of place where you can comfortably unwind on a busy Friday night or grab a quick, satisfying lunch thanks to their option of pizza by the slice. The staff’s accommodating nature adds a personal touch that elevates the dining experience, making you feel right at home from the moment you walk in.

While a few diners have noted that portions of toppings can sometimes feel modest, the overwhelming consensus celebrates the genuine quality and freshness of the pies. Regulars rave about the authenticity of the New York-style crust—so much so that Brooklyn-born pizza enthusiasts have hailed it as some of the best around. This pizzeria not only caters to classic preferences but also encourages trying unique combinations, even if, like one pepperoni-phile who ventured into pineapple territory, tastes may vary.

In essence, Bongiorno's New York Pizzeria offers more than just a meal—it offers a genuine slice of New York’s pizza heritage, right in Temecula. If you’re looking for a place where every bite carries the signature crisp softness of a perfectly made crust, accompanied by fresh, flavorful ingredients and thoughtful service, this pizzeria is well worth a visit.